Dale Murphy rookie card value and checklist (1977)

Best Dale Murphy Rookie Cards

Topps Rookie Catchers

1977 · Topps · #476

Open listings | View comps

Topps First Solo Card

1979 · Topps · #39

Open listings | View comps

Topps Rookie Cup / Catchers

1978 · Topps · #708 · All-Star Rookie Cup

Open listings | View comps

Values & Trends

Dale Murphy’s 1977 Topps #476 rookie card is a classic multi-player "Rookie Catchers" panel that commands strong interest from vintage collectors and Braves fans. While high-grade PSA 9s can reach into the thousands, nice raw copies remain accessible. Because his 1978 card is also a multi-player "Rookie Catchers" card, collectors often look to the 1979 Topps issue for his first true solo card.

The "Rookie Catchers" factor: Sharing the card with three other players (Gary Alexander, Rick Cerone, Kevin Pasley) makes centering and eye appeal challenging, as the layout is busy.
Solo card preference: The 1979 Topps #39 is widely collected as his first solo card appearance, while the 1978 Topps #708 remains popular for the "All-Star Rookie" trophy cup despite also being a multi-player card.
Condition sensitivity: The 1977 Topps paper stock is prone to print spots and soft corners, making high-grade examples significantly scarcer and more valuable.

Buying Guide: How to Pick Dale Murphy Rookie Cards

Target the 1977 Topps #476: This is the only recognized mainstream rookie card. Look for copies where Murphy (top left) is clearly printed and the borders are relatively centered.
Collect the "Rookie Cup" (1978 Topps #708): Though not a rookie and not a solo card, the 1978 issue features the iconic Topps All-Star Rookie Cup and is a key second-year card.
Add the First Solo Card (1979 Topps #39): For collectors who dislike multi-player panels, the 1979 Topps #39 is essential as the first card to feature Dale Murphy alone.
Watch for "Buyback" Autos: Since Murphy doesn't have a signed 1977 rookie in packs, modern "Topps Archives Signature Series" buybacks (original cards stamped and signed later) are a great way to get a certified auto on a vintage card.
Check grading economics: For mid-grade raw copies ($20–$40), grading fees might exceed the value increase. Focus grading efforts on sharp, well-centered candidates. Read our $80 grading rule guide for more details.

Full Rookie Card Checklist

Card	Year	#	Details	90d Avg RAW	90d Avg PSA 7	90d Avg PSA 8	90d Avg PSA 9	90d Avg SGC 8	90d Avg SGC 9	90d Avg SGC 9.5	eBay
Topps Rookie Catchers Dale Murphy · Topps	1977	476	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	eBay
Topps First Solo Card Dale Murphy · Topps	1979	39	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	—	eBay
Topps Rookie Cup / Catchers Dale Murphy · Topps All-Star Rookie Cup	1978	708		—	—	—	—	—	—	—	eBay

True RC vs. First Solo Card

The 1977 Topps #476 "Rookie Catchers" is universally accepted as Dale Murphy's true rookie card (RC). His 1978 Topps #708 features the "All-Star Rookie" cup but is still a multi-player card (shared with Lance Parrish and others). It wasn't until the 1979 Topps #39 that Dale Murphy received his first solo card. Most collectors aim to own all three to cover the RC, the Rookie Cup, and the first solo appearance.

Best Boxes & Sets to Pull Dale Murphy Rookie Cards

1977 Topps Baseball (Sealed Pack)
MLB
The only place to pull the flagship Dale Murphy RC.

Grading & Population

The 1977 Topps set is notoriously difficult to find in Gem Mint condition due to centering issues and print defects common in that era. PSA 10s are virtually non-existent relative to the total population, making PSA 9s the realistic "grail" for most high-end collectors.

Centering is key: With four players on the front, centering can be off in multiple directions. Eye appeal varies wildly even within the same technical grade.
Compare graders: PSA vs SGC vs CGC is a common debate for vintage. SGC is very popular for 1970s baseball cards due to their "tuxedo" slabs which frame vintage cards well.

About Dale Murphy

Dale Murphy, often called "Murph" or "The Gentle Giant," was one of baseball's premier players in the 1980s. A two-time National League MVP (1982, 1983) and a 7-time All-Star, he was the face of the Atlanta Braves for over a decade. Known for his clean image and powerful bat, Murphy remains a fan favorite. His exclusion from the Hall of Fame is a frequent topic of debate, keeping his rookie cards relevant as collectors speculate on a future induction.

Resources & Related Guides

FAQ

What is Dale Murphy’s true rookie card?

The 1977 Topps #476 "Rookie Catchers" card is the only generally accepted true rookie card for Dale Murphy. It features him alongside three other players.

When was Dale Murphy’s first solo card?

Dale Murphy’s first solo card is the 1979 Topps #39. His 1978 Topps card, which features the All-Star Rookie Cup, is still a multi-player "Rookie Catchers" panel.

Why is Dale Murphy not in the Hall of Fame?

Despite winning back-to-back MVPs (1982, 1983) and being a dominant player in the 80s, Murphy’s career totals fell short of traditional benchmarks (e.g., 400 HRs, 3000 hits) due to a sharp decline in his 30s. He remains a strong candidate for the Veterans Committee.

How much is a Dale Murphy rookie card worth?

A nice raw copy of the 1977 Topps #476 typically sells for $20 to $50 depending on condition. Graded copies in PSA 8 range from $80–$120, while PSA 9s can command $500 or more.

Should I grade my Dale Murphy rookie card?

Only if it is very sharp and well-centered. The 1977 Topps set is prone to centering issues. If your card is off-center or has soft corners, it is likely better to keep it raw, as a low grade (PSA 5 or 6) may not add much value over the raw price plus grading fees.