PSA vs CGC vs BGS vs SGC (2025): What to Grade & Why

Which Cards to Send to PSA, CGC, Beckett (BGS) or SGC — The Collector’s Guide (2025)

If you’re deciding where to grade your cards in 2025, here’s a clear, research-backed guide covering what to send where, up-to-date price ranges to expect, the “special hits” that can move markets, and a simple framework to choose with confidence.

TL;DR (quick picks)

• PSA: Flagship rookies, liquid modern, high-resale plays. PSA 10 Gem Mint. See: Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA)
• CGC: TCG (Pokémon, MTG, One Piece) and clean moderns. Chase CGC Pristine 10. See: CGC Cards
• Beckett (BGS): Condition‑sensitive moderns & autos when subgrades help; chase Black Label 10. See: Beckett
• SGC: Vintage & pre‑80s aesthetics and speed; rare SGC 10 Pristine Gold Label. See: SGC

The 2025 Price & Feature Snapshot

Prices change. Always double‑check live tiers and turnaround on the official service pages before submitting. The snapshot below reflects published information and current guides as of Oct 2, 2025.

Sources: PSA services, CGC Cards fees, Beckett grading, SGC services. Verify current pricing and ETAs before you submit.

What to Send Where (and Why)

🟥 PSA — When resale liquidity matters most

• Best for: Flagship rookies (Topps/Chrome, Prizm/Optic), globally liquid inserts, key Pokémon/TCG where liquidity beats niche.
• Why: PSA maintains the hobby’s broadest buyer pool; PSA 10 is the default “Gem” in many markets. See: Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA)
• Special hit: PSA 10 Gem Mint.
• Good to know (2025): Value tiers bumped in Sep 2025; check updated ETAs, declared value caps, and international submission policies.
• Send to PSA if: you want the highest average liquidity/premium across sports/TCG, especially for modern staples.

🟦 CGC — TCG specialist vibes, modern‑friendly

• Best for: Pokémon/MTG/One Piece/DBS and clean centering/surfaces; strong for modern non‑sports, too.
• Why: Competitive pricing and turnaround; Pristine 10 sits above Gem 10 on the current CGC scale. See: CGC Cards
• Special hit: CGC Pristine 10.
• Send to CGC if: you’re grading TCG at scale (bulk) or believe a card can flirt with Pristine 10.

🟨 Beckett (BGS) — Subgrades + Black Label ceiling

• Best for: Condition‑sensitive chromium, thick patch/autos, and cards where subgrades aid price discovery.
• Why: Subgrades (centering/edges/corners/surface) can justify stronger comps; Black Label (quad 10s) is a true chase. See: Beckett
• Special hits: BGS 10 Black Label (10/10/10/10 subgrades, ultra‑rare) BGS 10 Pristine (three 10s + one 9.5)
• Send to BGS if: you value subgrades or you’re realistically chasing Black Label perfection.

⬛️ SGC — Vintage authority, fast service, tuxedo look

• Best for: Vintage/pre‑war and classic sets (’50s–’70s); increasingly popular for modern as well.
• Why: Consistent grading, attractive black‑insert “tuxedo” slab, and quick standard service. See: SGC
• Special hit: SGC 10 Pristine (Gold Label) — rare and respected.
• Send to SGC if: you want vintage credibility, quick turnaround, or that tuxedo aesthetic for displays.

“Special Hits” — at a glance

• PSA: PSA 10 Gem Mint. See: Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA)
• CGC: CGC Pristine 10 (current apex; CGC Cards scale). See: CGC Cards
• BGS: BGS 10 Black Label (quad 10s; separate black label). See: Beckett
• SGC: SGC 10 Pristine “Gold Label.” See: SGC

How we decide in practice (simple framework)

• End goal: resale now (PSA/BGS) vs PC display (aesthetics = SGC; TCG set builds = CGC)
• Card type:
  • Flagship rookies / liquid modern: PSA (BGS if subgrades help)
  • TCG: CGC for bulk economics and label consistency; PSA for max liquidity See: CGC Cards
  • Vintage: SGC (or PSA if matching a registry run)
• Condition ceiling: If you truly see perfection, BGS for Black Label or CGC for Pristine 10. See: Beckett
• Budget & speed: Run the tier math before shipping; double‑check live pricing and ETAs on official pages. See: PSA · CGC · BGS · SGC

💡 Pro tip: Not sure if your card is worth grading? Learn about the expected value method that beats the $80 rule to make smarter grading decisions.

Pro tips (eye‑candy edition 💡✨)

• Screen first. Micro‑scratches and faint print lines kill 10s.
• Thick patches & autos: BGS subgrades + optional auto grade can help explain condition to buyers. See: Beckett
• TCG holo/foil: CGC and PSA both do well; if centering/surface are immaculate, try for CGC Pristine. See: CGC Cards
• Vintage gloss & registration: SGC's tuxedo frame makes color pop; pricing is friendly at the standard tier. See: SGC
• International: Check PSA's latest submission policies and current tariff considerations. See: PSA
• Security first: Before buying any graded card, learn to spot fake PSA slabs in 60 seconds to protect your investment.

FAQ

Which grading company has the best resale value? In general hobby practice, PSA tends to command the broadest liquidity; BGS Black Label and other pristine‑tier grades can outlier higher due to scarcity. See: PSA · Beckett

Does CGC still have “Perfect 10”? In 2025 CGC’s published scale features Pristine 10 as the apex grade. See: CGC Cards

Is SGC only for vintage? No — SGC is strong for vintage and increasingly used for modern, with competitive pricing and fast service. See: SGC

Do subgrades matter? They can help explain condition and improve comps on nuanced modern cards — Beckett is the go‑to for subgrades. See: Beckett