Patrick Mahomes II Rookie Cards: Values & Checklist (2017)

Best Patrick Mahomes II Rookie Cards

Prizm Rookie Card

2017 · Panini Prizm · #269

Open listings | View comps

Donruss Optic Rated Rookie

2017 · Donruss Optic · #177

Open listings | View comps

Select Premier Level Rookie

2017 · Select · #103

Open listings | View comps

Contenders Rookie Ticket Auto

2017 · Panini Contenders · #303 · Rookie Ticket Autograph

Open listings | View comps

National Treasures RPA

2017 · National Treasures · Rookie Patch Autograph /99

Open listings | View comps

Values & Trends

Patrick Mahomes II rookie cards sit at the top of the modern football market. His 2017 flagship pro-uniform rookies like Prizm #269 and Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #177 show strong demand across grades, while premium on-card autos and RPAs from sets such as National Treasures, Contenders, and Immaculate drive the highest sales.

Flagship base: 2017 Prizm and Donruss Optic provide accessible entry points, with raw copies and mid grades trading far below the five-figure autos but still reacting quickly to big games.
Premium autos and RPAs: On-card autographs and patch autos from 2017 National Treasures, Immaculate, Flawless, and Contenders often reach into the five-figure range in top grades, with low-serial Gold and 1/1 parallels leading the top sales (Cardboard Connection guide).
Scarcity and grade: Short-printed autos and low-serial parallels are heavily grade-sensitive; clean surfaces, centering, and corners can mean a large premium between top and mid-tier grades on the same card.

Buying Guide: How to Pick Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards

Start with flagship base RCs: 2017 Panini Prizm #269 and 2017 Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #177 are the go-to pro-uniform Mahomes rookies. They are widely recognized, have deep sales history, and appear in many entry- to mid-level budgets.
Add a premium chrome or field level: 2017 Select gives Mahomes both Premier Level #103 and Field Level #247 rookies, with Field Level being scarcer. These bridge the gap between flagship base and ultra-rare autos.
Target on-card autos: Contenders Rookie Ticket autos and Contenders Optic on-card autographs are hobby staples for quarterbacks. For higher budgets, 2017 National Treasures and Immaculate RPAs with low serials are often treated as grail-level pieces (Beckett overview).
Match grade to budget: Decide whether you want high-grade slabs or strong raw copies. Focus on centering, edges, and surface print lines on chromium cards; patches and autos should have clean signatures, minimal smudging, and appealing patch windows.
Plan grading carefully: grading guide and grading economics help you decide when a Mahomes rookie is worth sending in.

Full Rookie Card Checklist

Card	Year	#	Details	90d Avg RAW	90d Avg PSA 9	90d Avg PSA 10	eBay
Prizm Rookie Card Patrick Mahomes II · Panini Prizm	2017	269	—	—	—	—	eBay
Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Patrick Mahomes II · Donruss Optic	2017	177	—	—	—	—	eBay
Select Premier Level Rookie Patrick Mahomes II · Select	2017	103	—	—	—	—	eBay
Select Field Level Rookie Patrick Mahomes II · Select	2017	247	—	—	—	—	eBay
Contenders Rookie Ticket Auto Patrick Mahomes II · Panini Contenders Rookie Ticket Autograph	2017	303		—	—	—	eBay
Contenders Optic Rookie Ticket Auto Patrick Mahomes II · Contenders Optic Rookie Ticket Autograph	2017	103		—	—	—	eBay
National Treasures RPA Patrick Mahomes II · National Treasures Rookie Patch Autograph /99	2017			—	—	—	eBay
Immaculate Collection RPA Patrick Mahomes II · Immaculate Collection Rookie Patch Autograph	2017			—	—	—	eBay
Flawless Rookie Patch Auto Patrick Mahomes II · Panini Flawless Rookie Patch Autograph	2017			—	—	—	eBay
Origins Gold Ink Auto Patrick Mahomes II · Origins Gold Ink Autograph /25	2017			—	—	—	eBay

Prizm Rookie Card

2017 · Panini Prizm · #269

RAW

—

PSA 9

—

PSA 10

—

eBay

Donruss Optic Rated Rookie

2017 · Donruss Optic · #177

RAW

—

PSA 9

—

PSA 10

—

eBay

Select Premier Level Rookie

2017 · Select · #103

RAW

—

PSA 9

—

PSA 10

—

eBay

Select Field Level Rookie

2017 · Select · #247

RAW

—

PSA 9

—

PSA 10

—

eBay

Contenders Rookie Ticket Auto

2017 · Panini Contenders · #303

Rookie Ticket Autograph

RAW

—

PSA 9

—

PSA 10

—

eBay

Contenders Optic Rookie Ticket Auto

2017 · Contenders Optic · #103

Rookie Ticket Autograph

RAW

—

PSA 9

—

PSA 10

—

eBay

National Treasures RPA

2017 · National Treasures

Rookie Patch Autograph /99

RAW

—

PSA 9

—

PSA 10

—

eBay

Immaculate Collection RPA

2017 · Immaculate Collection

Rookie Patch Autograph

RAW

—

PSA 9

—

PSA 10

—

eBay

Flawless Rookie Patch Auto

2017 · Panini Flawless

Rookie Patch Autograph

RAW

—

PSA 9

—

PSA 10

—

eBay

Origins Gold Ink Auto

2017 · Origins

Gold Ink Autograph /25

RAW

—

PSA 9

—

PSA 10

—

eBay

True RCs, Autos, Patches, and Serials

The hobby treats Patrick Mahomes II’s true rookies as his 2017 pro-uniform NFL cards from core sets like Prizm, Donruss Optic, Select, and Contenders. College or prospect issues and later-year inserts are popular extras but sit outside this 2017 RC group. On-card autos and RPAs from premium lines such as National Treasures, Immaculate, Flawless, and Spectra are prized for their low serial numbers, game-themed patches, and stronger long-term demand among high-end collectors.

Best Boxes & Sets to Pull Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards

Grading & Population

Mahomes rookies see heavy grading volume, especially Prizm, Donruss Optic, and Contenders autos. High grades on chromium base and low-serial autos can bring large premiums, while strong-looking raw copies are still in demand with collectors who prefer to grade themselves.

Compare graders: PSA vs CGC vs BGS vs SGC to see how each handles modern football and chromium surfaces.
Review grading economics: the $80 rule before sending in lower-value base cards or heavily worn copies.
Stay alert for authenticity: quick fake slab checks are useful for high-end Mahomes autos and RPAs.

About Patrick Mahomes II

Patrick Mahomes II has become the defining quarterback of his era, leading the Kansas City Chiefs to multiple Super Bowl titles with a combination of arm talent, creativity, and late-game comebacks. Drafted in 2017 and taking over as starter in 2018, he quickly stacked MVP awards, playoff records, and historic passing numbers. That on-field resume keeps demand for his 2017 rookie cards and premium autos strong among both football collectors and investors.

Resources & Related Guides

FAQ

What is Patrick Mahomes II’s true rookie card?

Most collectors treat his 2017 pro-uniform NFL cards as the true rookies, especially 2017 Panini Prizm #269 and 2017 Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #177. Premium autos and RPAs from sets such as Contenders, National Treasures, and Immaculate are also part of his key 2017 rookie portfolio.

Which Patrick Mahomes rookie cards are the best to start with?

For most collectors, starting with 2017 Prizm #269 or Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #177 makes sense because they balance recognition, pricing tiers, and availability. From there, you can add Select Premier/Field Level and, if budget allows, a Contenders Rookie Ticket auto.

What are the most expensive Patrick Mahomes rookie cards?

Low-serial RPAs and on-card autos from 2017 National Treasures, Immaculate, Flawless, and Contenders often rank among his most expensive rookies in high grades, with strong five-figure sales reported for top copies on major marketplaces. Prices change over time, so always check recent sales snapshots before buying.

Should I grade a Patrick Mahomes rookie card?

Grading makes sense for clean copies with strong centering, sharp corners, and minimal print or surface issues, especially on Prizm, Optic, and premium autos. Lower-value or heavily worn cards can be better left raw unless they are part of a larger submission and still have clear upside in a higher grade.