Myles Garrett Rookie Cards: Values, Checklist & Best Picks

Best Myles Garrett Rookie Cards

Prizm Silver Rookie

2017 · Panini Prizm · #242 · Silver Prizm

Open listings | View comps

Donruss Rookie Card

2017 · Donruss · #356

Open listings | View comps

Donruss Optic Rookie Card

2017 · Donruss Optic · #106

Open listings | View comps

Select Field Level Rookie

2017 · Select · #105

Open listings | View comps

Values & Trends

Myles Garrett rookie cards are a good example of how the market treats elite defenders: flagship 2017 rookies like Prizm #242 and Optic Rated Rookie #106 are very liquid, while the biggest price spikes usually come from low-numbered parallels and premium autos. Because he plays edge rusher, values tend to move more on awards (like Defensive Player of the Year), sack races, and playoff runs than on weekly box scores.

Flagship base stays steady: If you want one “main” Myles Garrett rookie, Prizm #242 is the simplest anchor, and it has a deep sales history across raw and graded copies.
Parallels drive the ceiling: Silver and color parallels (especially low-serial /10 and 1/1) are where strong recent sales snapshots usually show up when collectors chase scarcity.
Condition matters on chromium: Prizm and Optic are surface-sensitive, so clean corners, sharp edges, and scratch-free fronts often separate an “average” copy from a grading candidate.

Buying Guide: How to Pick Myles Garrett Rookie Cards

Start with the pro-uniform 2017 flagship and keep it simple: 2017 Panini Prizm #242 is the cleanest “true RC” starting point for most collectors.
Add a second look for variety: Donruss #356 and Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #106 are popular companion rookies with a different design feel and plenty of comps.
Choose your scarcity level by deciding whether you want base, Silver, or a numbered parallel. For most budgets, Silver is the sweet spot between availability and “it feels special.”
Inspect surfaces like you are grading even if you plan to keep the card raw. Ask for angled photos to catch scratches, print lines, and edge whitening on Prizm and Optic.
Use slab filters to price by grade and learn what the market actually pays for PSA 9 vs PSA 10 on the exact card you want. If you are new to football slabs, see the football slab value guide .
Buy like a collector, not a headline: check recent sold listings, confirm the card number in photos, and avoid confusing college/draft issues with pro-uniform NFL rookies. For a step-by-step marketplace workflow, use the eBay buying guide .

Full Rookie Card Checklist

Card	Year	#	Details	90d Avg RAW	90d Avg PSA 9	90d Avg PSA 10	eBay
Prizm Silver Rookie Myles Garrett · Panini Prizm Silver Prizm	2017	242		—	—	—	eBay
Donruss Rookie Card Myles Garrett · Donruss	2017	356	—	—	—	—	eBay
Donruss Optic Rookie Card Myles Garrett · Donruss Optic	2017	106	—	—	—	—	eBay
Select Field Level Rookie Myles Garrett · Select	2017	105	—	—	—	—	eBay
Contenders Season Ticket Rookie Myles Garrett · Panini Contenders Season Ticket	2017	44		—	—	—	eBay
Classics Rookie Card Myles Garrett · Panini Classics	2017	270	—	—	—	—	eBay
National Treasures Base Rookie Myles Garrett · National Treasures Purple /75 Serial /75	2017	92		—	—	—	eBay
Prizm Gold Rookie Parallel Myles Garrett · Panini Prizm Gold /10 Serial /10	2017	242		—	—	—	eBay
Optic Holo Rookie Parallel Myles Garrett · Donruss Optic Holo	2017	106		—	—	—	eBay

True RC, Autos and Serials

For Myles Garrett, most collectors treat his 2017 pro-uniform NFL cards as the true rookies, led by Prizm #242 plus core Donruss and Optic issues. Earlier college and draft cards can be fun pre-rookies, but they are usually priced and collected separately. If you want to move up the ladder, focus on numbered Prizm parallels, Optic Holos, and premium autograph sets where scarcity and condition do most of the work for long-term demand.

Best Boxes & Sets to Pull Myles Garrett Rookie Cards

Grading & Population

2017 Prizm and Optic rookies are popular grading targets, but they are not “free PSA 10s.” Centering, small corner dings, and faint surface scratches are common reasons strong-looking raw copies land in lower slabs. If you are grading for value, it is usually smarter to be picky on condition than to submit every copy you find.

If you are buying graded, compare multiple examples in the same grade and pick the one with the best eye appeal, not just the cheapest label.
If you are buying raw to grade, prioritize surface quality on Prizm and Optic, then check corners and edges under bright light.
If you are new to submissions, the PSA submission walkthrough helps you avoid the most common first-time mistakes.

About Myles Garrett

Myles Garrett is a Cleveland Browns edge rusher and former first overall pick (2017) who has spent his career as one of the league’s most consistent pressure players. He has even leaned into the “Godzilla” and “King of the Monsters” nickname at times, which collectors will sometimes use in searches. In the card market, he is valued as a modern defensive cornerstone, which shows up most clearly in the liquidity of his 2017 Prizm #242 and Optic Rated Rookie #106, and in the premium for clean high-grade slabs and scarce parallels when award seasons and sack races bring new attention.

Resources & Related Guides

FAQ

What is Myles Garrett’s true rookie card?

Most collectors treat Myles Garrett’s true rookies as his 2017 pro-uniform NFL cards, with 2017 Panini Prizm #242 being the flagship. Donruss #356 and Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #106 are also widely collected 2017 RCs.

How much is a Myles Garrett rookie card worth?

Values vary most by set and grade. Base Prizm, Donruss, and Optic rookies can be affordable in raw or mid-grade slabs, while Silver and low-numbered parallels usually sell for more. Always check recent sales snapshots for the exact card and grade you are buying.

Which Myles Garrett rookie card is best to start with?

If you want one card that is easy to buy and resell, start with 2017 Panini Prizm #242. If you want a second “upgrade” look, consider Optic Rated Rookie #106 or Prizm Silver, depending on your budget.

Are defensive player rookie cards a good buy?

They can be, especially for elite, award-winning defenders with long careers. The main difference is that demand is often steadier and less headline-driven than it is for quarterbacks, so scarcity and condition (Silvers, numbered parallels, clean slabs) tend to matter more than weekly stats.

Should I grade a Myles Garrett rookie card?

Grading makes the most sense for clean chromium rookies with strong centering, sharp corners, and scratch-free surfaces, especially Prizm and Optic. Well-loved copies can be better kept raw if grading fees would eat up most of the card’s value.

Where can I buy Myles Garrett rookie cards?

Large marketplaces like eBay usually have the widest selection across raw and graded copies. Use set and card-number filters, review photos closely, and compare recent sold listings before you commit to a price.