James Pearce Jr. Rookie Cards: Values & Checklist (2025)

Best James Pearce Jr. Rookie Cards

Score Rookie Card

2025 · Score · #26

Open listings | View comps

Phoenix Rookie Card

2025 · Phoenix · #243

Open listings | View comps

Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Preview

2025 · Donruss · #363 · Optic Rated Rookies Preview Red Pandora

Open listings | View comps

Phoenix Wave Rookie

2025 · Phoenix · #243 · Wave

Open listings | View comps

Bowman Chrome University Prospect Auto

2024 · Bowman Chrome University · #PA-JPE · Prospect Autographs

Open listings | View comps

Values & Trends

James Pearce Jr.'s rookie market is still early, so the page is easier to read than many quarterback markets. Most collectors start with cheap 2025 pro-uniform rookies like Score #26 and Phoenix #243, while the modest premium sits in scarcer cards such as Phoenix Wave /199, Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Preview color, and his 2024 Bowman Chrome University autograph from Tennessee.

Performance-sensitive market: Edge rushers usually need sacks, highlight plays, and a visible role before base rookies move meaningfully.
Scarcity matters more than base: Right now, collectors pay up faster for numbered Phoenix parallels and harder-to-find preview color than for common base RCs.
Grade discipline still helps: On low-dollar base cards, grading only makes sense for very clean copies, but strong centering and surfaces matter more once you step into foil and serial-numbered cards.

Buying Guide: How to Pick James Pearce Jr. Rookie Cards

Start with the true RC pair: 2025 Score #26 and 2025 Phoenix #243 are the easiest James Pearce Jr. rookies to find, compare, and price across raw and graded copies.
Use the card number in every search: modern rookie searches get noisy fast, and the number helps you avoid unrelated college cards, parallels, and team-set listings.
Separate NFL rookies from college pre-rookies: 2024 Bowman Chrome University autos can be good buys, but they are prospect cards rather than James Pearce Jr.'s true NFL rookie cards.
Only pay a premium when scarcity is clear: if a seller is asking up for a Wave /199, Gold, or preview color card, make sure the serial, parallel name, and photos all match the listing title.
Keep marketplace risk low: use sold listings for context, zoom into surfaces on foil cards, and favor return-friendly sellers for higher-end parallels and autos. How to buy sports cards on eBay .

Full Rookie Card Checklist

Card	Year	#	Details	90d Avg RAW	90d Avg PSA 9	90d Avg PSA 10	eBay
Score Rookie Card James Pearce Jr. · Score	2025	26	—	—	—	—	eBay
Phoenix Rookie Card James Pearce Jr. · Phoenix	2025	243	—	—	—	—	eBay
Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Preview James Pearce Jr. · Donruss Optic Rated Rookies Preview Red Pandora	2025	363		—	—	—	eBay
Phoenix Wave Rookie James Pearce Jr. · Phoenix Wave Serial /199	2025	243		—	—	—	eBay
Bowman Chrome University Prospect Auto James Pearce Jr. · Bowman Chrome University Prospect Autographs Auto	2024	PA-JPE		—	—	—	eBay
Revolution Rookies James Pearce Jr. · Revolution Rookies	2025	218		—	—	—	eBay

True RC, Autos, Patches, Serials

For James Pearce Jr., collectors generally treat his 2025 pro-uniform Falcons cards as the true rookie card group. That means cards like Score #26, Phoenix #243, Revolution Rookies #218, and Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Preview #363 matter more for mainstream rookie collectors than 2024 Bowman University cards. Bowman Chrome University autographs are still relevant because they give you an early Tennessee prospect auto, but they sit in the pre-rookie lane rather than the true NFL RC lane. Since the market is still young, the premium tier is mostly serial-numbered parallels and autos instead of one fully established grail rookie.

Best Boxes & Sets to Pull James Pearce Jr. Rookie Cards

Grading & Population

James Pearce Jr. rookies are early enough that grading should be selective. Base Score and Revolution cards are easy to replace, so most collectors should only submit copies with clean corners and sharp centering, while foil-heavy Phoenix and preview-color cards deserve closer surface checks before you chase a PSA 10 premium.

If you are buying slabs, use this football-specific guide to understand what usually drives the premium: identify valuable football card slabs .
If you are grading raw cards, compare the jump from raw to PSA 9 and PSA 10 first so you are not spending grading fees on cards that are still cheap in top holders.
For chrome and foil stock, ask for close-ups of corners and surfaces before buying an expensive parallel.

About James Pearce Jr.

James Pearce Jr. is an edge rusher from Tennessee who entered the NFL as a first-round pick in 2025 with the Atlanta Falcons. He built his draft stock with burst, length, and consistent SEC production, which makes him more interesting to defensive-card collectors than a typical low-profile rookie defender. In the hobby, though, pass rushers usually need real NFL production to move fast, so Pearce remains a budget-friendly rookie-card bet with upside if his sack totals and role grow.

Resources & Related Guides

FAQ

What are James Pearce Jr.'s flagship rookie cards?

The clearest flagship-style James Pearce Jr. rookie cards right now are 2025 Score #26 and 2025 Phoenix #243. They are the easiest true NFL rookies to find, price, and compare across raw and graded copies.

How much is a James Pearce Jr. rookie card worth?

Most James Pearce Jr. base rookies still trade at low-dollar levels, often in the low-single-digits raw. Scarcer cards such as Phoenix Wave /199 parallels, preview color, and his 2024 Bowman Chrome University autograph can sell higher, so always check the exact set, card number, and version before using a price as a comp.

What is the true James Pearce Jr. rookie card?

Collectors generally treat his 2025 pro-uniform Falcons cards as the true rookie card group. That includes cards like 2025 Score #26, 2025 Phoenix #243, 2025 Revolution Rookies #218, and 2025 Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Preview #363.

Are 2024 Bowman University James Pearce Jr. cards true rookies?

No. Most collectors treat 2024 Bowman University cards as pre-rookie or prospect cards because they show James Pearce Jr. in his college Tennessee context rather than his NFL rookie-year pro-uniform card group.

Which James Pearce Jr. card is the best buy right now?

For most collectors, 2025 Phoenix #243 is the best all-around starting point because it is a true rookie card with better visual appeal than many entry-level base cards. If you want a cheaper first buy, Score #26 works. If you want more upside, look at Phoenix Wave /199 or the Bowman Chrome University auto.

Should I grade James Pearce Jr. rookie cards?

Grading makes the most sense for very clean copies of foil and chrome-style cards where a PSA 10 premium can matter. For cheap base cards, it is usually smarter to buy the slab you want rather than submit average raw copies.

Where can I buy James Pearce Jr. rookie cards?

Use the live listings search at the top of this page and search by exact set and card number. That is the easiest way to separate true NFL rookies from college-era cards, compare raw against graded copies, and avoid overpaying for common base versions.