Mahomes 2025 NT NFL Shield 1/1 BGS 9.5 Goldin Sale

2025 Panini National Treasures Colossal Materials NFL Shield Patrick Mahomes II 1/1 Sells for $17,418 at Goldin

On June 7, 2026, Goldin sold a major modern football grail: a 2025 Panini National Treasures Colossal Materials NFL Shield #CMS-PMS Patrick Mahomes II patch card, serial-numbered 1/1 and graded BGS GEM MINT 9.5, for $17,418.

For collectors who focus on ultra-modern football and high-end patches, this sale offers a useful snapshot of where top-tier Mahomes memorabilia cards are landing in early 2026.

The card at a glance

Here’s how this card breaks down:

• Player: Patrick Mahomes II, Kansas City Chiefs (QB)
• Year: 2025
• Set: Panini National Treasures Football
• Subset: Colossal Materials
• Card number: #CMS-PMS
• Parallel / version: NFL Shield patch, serial-numbered 1/1
• Autograph: None noted – this is a premium patch-only memorabilia card
• Patch type: NFL Shield, typically a piece of the shield logo from the jersey collar
• Grading company: Beckett Grading Services (BGS)
• Grade: GEM MINT 9.5
• Slab details: Subgrades are not specified in the sale summary, but a BGS 9.5 on a thick, high-end patch card is considered a strong result.

This is not a rookie card (Mahomes’ rookies are from 2017 products), but it is a key ultra-modern, high-end memorabilia piece from a flagship premium brand.

Why National Treasures and shield patches matter

Panini National Treasures (NT) is widely treated as one of the hobby’s premier high-end football brands. It features:

• Low serial-numbered cards
• On-card autographs in many subsets
• Large, often game-worn or player-worn patches
• Case-hit level chases such as true RPA (Rookie Patch Auto) cards and shield patches

Within NT, “Colossal Materials” showcases oversized memorabilia windows. The NFL Shield patch is typically the most premium form of jersey memorabilia in a set, often reserved for cards numbered to 1 (true one-of-ones). Shield cards sit near the top of the hierarchy for player collectors and high-end memorabilia buyers.

Even without an autograph, an NT 1/1 shield patch of a top-tier quarterback like Mahomes is considered a centerpiece card. It appeals to:

• Player collectors who chase Mahomes at the highest level
• Team/PC (personal collection) collectors focused on the Chiefs
• High-end modern investors and flippers who target scarce, visually striking, low-serial cards

Market context and price positioning

The card sold at Goldin for $17,418.

When looking at comps (short for “comparables,” meaning recent sales of the same or similar cards used to gauge market value), the closest points of reference for this card are:

• Other Mahomes NFL Shield 1/1s from National Treasures and Flawless
• High-end Mahomes 1/1 non-rookie patches from premium brands
• The broader tier of modern, non-rookie 1/1 shield cards for elite quarterbacks

Because this is a 2025 non-rookie shield, it falls into a different lane than Mahomes’ 2017 NT true RPAs or early-career shield autos. Those historically trade and auction at substantially higher levels, especially in top grades and with on-card autographs.

Recent market behavior (early 2025 through mid-2026) around similar Mahomes cards suggests a few patterns:

1. Rookie content dominates the very top end. 2017 NT RPAs, 2017 Contenders autos, and early Flawless shields tend to command the biggest premiums.
2. Non-rookie 1/1 shields still draw strong results. While they sit below rookie cards in the Mahomes hierarchy, they often close in the mid–four to low–five-figure range depending on:
   • Brand (NT and Flawless at the top)
   • Whether there is an autograph
   • Patch quality and eye appeal
   • Timing relative to the NFL season and Mahomes’ performance
3. Condition matters more than many expect for thick patch cards. Surface and corner wear are common on thicker, high-end cards, so a BGS 9.5 remains a helpful differentiator versus raw copies.

Within that context, the $17,418 result at Goldin sits in a zone that:

• Reflects the premium status of Panini National Treasures as a brand
• Acknowledges Mahomes’ established, long-term hobby stature rather than speculative hype
• Is consistent with other non-rookie 1/1 shield-level memorabilia for elite quarterbacks in the current environment

Exact comps for this specific 2025 NT Colossal Materials Shield 1/1 are naturally limited—by definition, there is only one copy. However, its realized price lines up with the broader structure of Mahomes’ high-end non-rookie memorabilia market.

Ultra-modern era and scarcity

This card sits firmly in the ultra-modern era (roughly mid-2010s to present), where:

• Print runs are more transparent (serial numbering, 1/1s, etc.)
• Products are structured around a wide range of parallels and inserts
• Grading is common from the start of a card’s life cycle

In ultra-modern, true scarcity comes from:

• Serial numbering (especially 1/1)
• Brand hierarchy (NT, Flawless, Immaculate, etc.)
• Player tier (in this case, one of the era’s defining QBs)

A one-of-one shield from a top brand checks all three boxes. Even though there is more manufactured rarity in the modern hobby than in earlier eras, a key Mahomes shield 1/1 still has a clear place in the long-term supply picture: there simply will never be another copy of this exact card.

Mahomes’ hobby standing in 2026

By mid-2026, Patrick Mahomes has already built a resume that puts him firmly in the “chasing all-time great” conversation, with multiple Super Bowl appearances and wins, MVP-level seasons, and a consistent presence in the playoffs.

For the hobby, that matters because:

• His rookie-year cards are now seen as foundational modern football pieces.
• His non-rookie high-end cards—especially from top brands and in 1/1 or shield formats—function as important supplemental holdings for collectors who already own (or are priced out of) his best rookies.

Changes in Mahomes’ on-field performance, postseason results, and awards can still influence short-term interest, but by 2026 his place as a top-tier modern QB collectible is established enough that market swings are more about adjusting expectations than building them from scratch.

BGS 9.5 on a thick, high-end patch card

The BGS GEM MINT 9.5 grade is relevant here for a couple of reasons:

1. Thick cards are harder to gem. National Treasures cards are thicker than standard base cards. Corners and edges often pick up minor dings right out of the pack.
2. Patch windows can introduce defects. Surface and print imperfections around large patch windows are common. A 9.5 signals that the card avoided many typical issues.

For collectors who care about both eye appeal and long-term condition, a 9.5 BGS label can be a meaningful quality marker. While some modern collectors increasingly prefer PSA for registry and liquidity reasons, BGS still has a long-established foothold in high-end patch/autograph cards, especially from the 2000s and 2010s onward.

How collectors might interpret this sale

For active hobbyists, this Goldin sale can be read a few ways:

• Benchmark for non-rookie Mahomes shields: It helps set expectations for where future National Treasures or Flawless 1/1 shield patches (with or without autos) might land, recognizing differences in year, design, and brand tier.
• Reference point for other ultra-modern QBs: When comparing high-end cards of rising quarterbacks, this result serves as a reminder of the gap between “potential star” and a player already in the all-time conversation.
• Data point for thick-card grading decisions: Seeing a thick, shield-level Mahomes 1/1 perform well in BGS 9.5 reassures some collectors that grading premium memorabilia still has a place in the modern market structure.

None of this should be taken as financial advice or as a prediction of where Mahomes’ cards—or the broader market—will go next. It is one sale, in one auction, at one point in time. But as part of the bigger picture of Mahomes’ high-end market, this result is informative.

Takeaways for new and returning collectors

If you’re newer to the hobby or returning after a break, here are a few practical lessons from this sale:

1. Learn the brand hierarchy. National Treasures, Flawless, and a handful of other products tend to anchor the modern high-end football market. Knowing which sets matter most helps you interpret prices.
2. Understand card types. A non-rookie patch 1/1, a rookie patch auto, and a rookie base card each occupy a different lane in the hobby. Comparing across those lanes can be misleading.
3. Use comps carefully. For 1/1s, there are no true direct comps. Instead, look at similarly important cards of the same player from related sets and years to get a range rather than a single “correct” price.
4. Condition is still key. Even in the ultra-modern era, high grades on difficult card types (thick, patch, foil-heavy) can be real differentiators.

The 2025 Panini National Treasures Colossal Materials NFL Shield #CMS-PMS Patrick Mahomes II 1/1, BGS 9.5, sold for $17,418 at Goldin on June 7, 2026, stands as a clean example of how the market currently values non-rookie, ultra-premium Mahomes memorabilia. For collectors tracking the top end of modern football, it’s a notable data point—and for dedicated Mahomes or Chiefs collectors, it’s the kind of piece that can quietly anchor a collection for years.