Mahomes 2017 Prizm Red Power Rookie PSA 10 Sells

2017 Panini Prizm Red Power Prizm #269 Patrick Mahomes II Rookie Card (#37/49) PSA 10 Sells for $62,830 at Goldin

On January 4, 2026, Goldin closed a notable ultra‑modern football sale: a 2017 Panini Prizm Red Power Prizm #269 Patrick Mahomes II Rookie Card, serial‑numbered 37/49 and graded PSA GEM MT 10, realized $62,830.

For Mahomes collectors and Prizm enthusiasts, this result sits in an important middle ground: not the eye‑watering record territory of his ultra‑premium issues, but clearly a high‑confidence number for a scarce color‑match rookie in top grade.

Card snapshot: what exactly sold?

Let’s break down the key details of the card:

• Year & product: 2017 Panini Prizm Football
• Player: Patrick Mahomes II, Kansas City Chiefs
• Card number: #269
• Type: Rookie card (RC)
• Parallel: Red Power Prizm
• Serial numbering: #37/49 (only 49 copies produced)
• Grading company: PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator)
• Grade: GEM MT 10 (PSA’s highest standard grade)

2017 Prizm is widely treated as Mahomes’ flagship chromium rookie in the mainstream hobby. Within that set, the limited‑print parallels – especially those with strong visual appeal – have become important long‑term reference points for his market.

The Red Power Prizm parallel is:

• Serial‑numbered to 49 copies
• A bold red pattern that visually pairs well with the Kansas City Chiefs’ colors (often called a “color match” in hobby slang)
• Non‑autographed and non‑patch, but driven by scarcity, brand strength, and grade

Why this card matters to collectors

1. Flagship Mahomes rookie + scarce color parallel

Panini Prizm is one of the key brands for modern and ultra‑modern football. For many collectors, Prizm base and color rookies function like the modern equivalent of a vintage Topps rookie: widely recognized, easy to understand, and deeply liquid.

Within that structure:

• Base Rookie (#269): high‑volume, more affordable entry point.
• Numbered color parallels (like Red Power /49): short‑print versions that sit higher on the ladder of scarcity and prestige.

Red Power isn’t the rarest Mahomes Prizm parallel (there are lower serial runs and special case hits), but at 49 copies total, it is firmly in the “true limited” category, especially once you factor in condition and grading.

2. PSA 10 in a low‑print parallel

A PSA 10 (GEM MT) means PSA viewed the card as essentially flawless within their standard – sharp corners, strong centering for the issue, and clean surfaces.

For a chromium card like Prizm, that matters because:

• Surface scratching and print lines are common.
• Centering can be inconsistent on 2017 Prizm.

So while 49 copies exist on paper, only a portion of those will achieve PSA 10 status. The effective population of top‑grade copies is significantly lower than the raw print run.

When collectors talk about “pop report” (population report), they mean the grading company’s count of how many copies exist at each grade. Even without quoting specific numbers here, the general pattern is clear across 2017 Prizm Mahomes parallels: PSA 10s in low‑serial color are much scarcer than the raw serial number suggests.

3. Mahomes’ place in the modern QB hierarchy

Patrick Mahomes has already stacked:

• Multiple Super Bowl appearances and wins
• Multiple MVP‑level seasons
• A reputation for elite playoff performance

In hobby terms, he has moved from “promising young QB” into the conversation as one of the key modern quarterback pillars alongside names like Tom Brady and Peyton Manning. That shift has helped establish 2017 Prizm Mahomes color as a core segment of the ultra‑modern football market.

Market context: how does $62,830 fit in?

When collectors talk about “comps” (comparable sales), they mean recent, confirmed sale prices for the same card or very similar ones. Comps help frame what a new sale might reasonably land at.

For Mahomes’ 2017 Prizm color rookies, the market has shown a few consistent patterns over the last several years:

• Serial‑numbered Prizm color (like Red, Blue, Orange, and pattern parallels) has held a premium over non‑numbered Silver, driven by clear, printed scarcity.
• Color‑match parallels (reds for Chiefs) often carry additional demand because the card visually ties to the team colors.
• PSA 10 examples of numbered Mahomes Prizm rookies have generally commanded a strong multiple over raw or lower‑grade copies, especially at /75 and lower.

Within that landscape, a PSA 10 Red Power /49 achieving $62,830 on January 4, 2026 at Goldin is consistent with how collectors have been treating:

• Scarce, numbered Mahomes Prizm rookies in elite grade
• Non‑auto, non‑patch cards that are nonetheless considered “pillars” of his rookie market

When you compare to Mahomes’ very top‑end cards – like National Treasures Rookie Patch Autos (RPAs) or ultra‑low‑serial Prizm and Optic parallels – this sale sits below record territory. However, for a non‑auto, non‑patch Prizm parallel, it reflects sustained confidence in this lane of his market.

Rather than a sudden spike out of nowhere, this result fits into the existing pattern where:

• True rookie parallels from flagship sets remain highly respected.
• Color‑match, low‑serial, PSA 10 Mahomes cards are treated as long‑term centerpieces by many collectors.

How collectors might interpret this result

Again, none of this is financial advice, but it’s useful to look at how different types of collectors may read a sale like this.

For Mahomes‑focused collectors

This card is one of the stronger non‑auto rookie pieces you can own:

• Key brand (Prizm)
• True rookie card
• Serial‑numbered to 49
• PSA 10 grade

A $62,830 result at Goldin in early 2026 reinforces that well‑centered, sharp copies in top grade still command meaningful attention and liquidity.

For Prizm and color‑parallel collectors

The sale underlines a few ongoing themes in ultra‑modern:

• Numbered color remains an important tier above non‑numbered parallels.
• PSA 10 condition pushes a clear premium, especially in low‑print runs.
• Established stars with strong resumes (rather than short‑term hype) continue to anchor the high end of Prizm color markets.

For collectors building color‑parallel rainbows or focusing on specific parallels, the Red Power /49 Mahomes sale provides a clear, public data point on where this tier currently sits.

For newcomers and returning collectors

If you’re newer to the hobby, this sale is a practical example of how modern football value tends to concentrate:

1. Player: proven star quarterbacks typically drive the strongest markets.
2. Set: flagship products like Prizm, Optic, and Select usually become reference points for rookie years.
3. Parallel & print run: numbered parallels (like /49) with clear scarcity tend to sit above base and non‑numbered parallels.
4. Grade: a top grade from a leading grader (PSA, BGS, SGC) often carries a significant premium.

You don’t need to chase five‑figure cards to apply these ideas. The same framework can help you evaluate more affordable rookies from current or recent classes.

Takeaways for small sellers and hobbyists

For small sellers and active hobbyists, a sale like this can serve as a reference point when you’re sorting and pricing your own cards:

• Check serial numbers: even non‑auto Prizm parallels with print runs like /199, /149, /99, or /75 can have healthy demand if the player is strong.
• Inspect condition carefully: a card that might be a routine sale raw can become a major piece if it grades a 10 with PSA or another major grading company.
• Use comp data where available: look at recent sales on auction houses and marketplaces for the same card, grade, and parallel when pricing. When exact comps are thin, use related parallels and grades to build a rough range.

The $62,830 sale of the 2017 Panini Prizm Red Power Prizm #269 Patrick Mahomes II Rookie Card (#37/49) PSA GEM MT 10 at Goldin on January 4, 2026 doesn’t rewrite the Mahomes market, but it does reaffirm how the hobby is currently valuing:

• Flagship rookie parallels
• True, transparent scarcity
• Top‑tier grades

For collectors building Mahomes PCs (personal collections) or studying the structure of modern football markets, this card is another useful benchmark in the ongoing story of ultra‑modern quarterback collecting.