2023 Select Black Prizm 1/1 Michael Penix Jr. PSA 9 Sale

2023 Panini Select Black Prizm #504 Michael Penix Jr. Rookie Card (#1/1) - PSA MINT 9 Sells for $16,470

On January 9, 2026, Goldin closed the sale of a major ultra‑modern football card: a 2023 Panini Select Black Prizm #504 Michael Penix Jr. Rookie Card, serial‑numbered 1/1 and graded PSA MINT 9, realized $16,470.

For collectors tracking high‑end Michael Penix Jr. cards and key modern football rookies, this result offers a useful data point on how the hobby is currently valuing one‑of‑one Select parallels early in a quarterback’s career.

The card at a glance

Let’s break down exactly what this card is:

• Year: 2023
• Brand / Set: Panini Select Football
• Card number: #504
• Player: Michael Penix Jr.
• Rookie status: Yes – this is a rookie card from his first Select NFL release
• Parallel: Black Prizm (the true 1/1 color parallel in many Panini chromium sets)
• Serial numbering: 1/1 (one‑of‑one)
• Grading company: PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator)
• Grade: PSA MINT 9

There is no higher‑numbered version of this specific parallel. While there may be other premium Penix rookies — for example, Gold Prizm /10, Green /5, or different brands such as Prizm, Optic, or National Treasures — there is only one copy of this exact Black Prizm #504 in existence.

Why this card matters to collectors

1. A true 1/1 Black Prizm rookie

In modern Panini chromium products, Black Prizm is typically the top non‑autograph color parallel and is usually a one‑of‑one. Collectors often view it as:

• The “color apex” of the rainbow
• A centerpiece for player collectors
• A direct reference point for how the market values that player’s non‑auto rookies

For Michael Penix Jr., this means the 2023 Select Black Prizm #504 is one of the most important non‑autograph rookies he has.

2. Ultra‑modern quarterback market

This card sits firmly in the ultra modern era (roughly mid‑2010s to present), where:

• Supply of base cards is high
• Key value tends to concentrate in rare parallels, low serial numbers, and on‑card autographs
• Quarterbacks in particular drive a large share of football card demand

A one‑of‑one Black Prizm rookie of a starting or ascending quarterback is the exact sort of card many modern football collectors watch closely. It reflects both hobby sentiment and broader expectations around the player’s future performance.

3. The role of Select in the hierarchy

Within Panini’s football portfolio, Select typically sits as a premium chromium set alongside Prizm and Optic. Many collectors think of the pecking order like this:

• Prizm: Often treated as the flagship chromium rookie
• Select: A bit more niche but highly respected; known for multiple field‑level tiers and strong parallel structure
• Optic / Contenders Optic: Popular, especially for on‑card autos

Because of that, a top‑tier parallel from Select — especially a one‑of‑one Black Prizm rookie — tends to attract serious player collectors and investors in the high‑end modern market.

The sale: $16,470 at Goldin

Goldin reported a final sale price of $16,470 for this card on January 4, 2026.

A few key contextual points:

• Auction house: Goldin is one of the major high‑end marketplaces for sports and TCG cards. Their results are often used as reference points for “comps.”
• What are comps? Comps (comparable sales) are recent sale prices of the same or similar items, used by collectors to get a feel for current market value. They are not guarantees of future results, just reference data.

Because this card is a true 1/1, there are no direct, repeated sales of the exact same graded copy to compare against. For one‑of‑ones, the market usually triangulates using:

• Sales of other premium Penix rookie parallels (Gold /10, Green /5, etc.)
• One‑of‑one cards from other brands (Prizm, Optic, National Treasures, Flawless)
• Market history for similar quarterbacks at similar stages of their careers

Market context and comps

For a one‑of‑one rookie card like this, “typical” pricing is hard to define. The buyer and underbidders effectively establish the market in that moment, particularly when the sale runs through a major auction house.

Looking across recent hobby behavior for similar ultra‑modern quarterbacks, we can outline some broad tendencies that likely influence this result:

• Brand weighting: True 1/1 rookies from Prizm, National Treasures (especially RPA – Rookie Patch Autographs), Flawless, and Select often sit in the top tier of a player’s card hierarchy.
• Autograph premium: On‑card autographs and patch autos are frequently valued higher than non‑auto parallels, even when both are low‑serial. That context matters when comparing a non‑auto Black Prizm to, say, a 1/1 National Treasures RPA.
• Grade sensitivity: For a one‑of‑one, the grade still matters, but scarcity softens the effect. A PSA 9 can be very strong because there is no competition from a second copy in PSA 10; the only alternative is raw or another grading company.

At the time of this sale, public, repeatable comps for this exact 2023 Select Black Prizm #504 in PSA 9 are inherently limited, because:

• The card is unique (1/1)
• Single‑owner, high‑end one‑of‑ones often change hands privately or infrequently

That’s why collectors tend to use a cluster of recent sales of Penix’s other major rookies to view the $16,470 result as one additional point in a broader pattern, rather than a precise pricing formula.

Grading and population context

The card is graded PSA MINT 9, which means:

• Strong overall condition
• Very minor flaws allowed (slight corner touch, tiny surface mark, or minor centering issue)

For a one‑of‑one parallel, the population report (or “pop report”) matters in a different way than for base rookies:

• What is a pop report? A population report is a published count from a grading company showing how many copies of a card they have graded at each grade level.
• With a 1/1, the maximum PSA pop can never exceed 1 for each grade.

Even if another grading company (BGS, SGC, etc.) were to grade a raw copy, there is still only one physical card. The PSA 9 label simply adds an additional layer of confidence in condition and authenticity.

How collectors can use this sale as a reference

This Goldin result doesn’t predict what Penix’s cards will do next, but it can be a useful data point in several ways:

1. Benchmark for non‑auto Select parallels
   For Michael Penix Jr., this $16,470 hammer (rounded final price) sets an early reference point for how the market currently views his very top Select non‑auto rookie parallel.

2. Comparison across brands
   Collectors can place this sale next to recent results for Penix’s major Prizm, Optic, and National Treasures rookies to get a relative sense of how Select is priced versus other key brands.

3. Risk and timing awareness
   Ultra‑modern quarterback cards, especially one‑of‑ones, are very sensitive to performance, injuries, and team context. This sale simply reflects how the market felt on January 9, 2026 — not a forward guarantee.

4. Guide for new and returning collectors
   For anyone just re‑entering the hobby, this sale illustrates:

   • The premium placed on color‑match and top‑tier parallels
   • Why serial numbering and grading are so central to modern pricing
   • How auction houses like Goldin anchor the upper end of the market

Takeaways for hobbyists and small sellers

If you are a Penix collector, a modern football fan, or a small seller trying to understand the landscape, here are a few practical observations:

• Scarcity is layered. A 1/1 parallel like this is scarce by design. That scarcity compounds with a strong grade and a respected brand.
• Set positioning matters. Select might not always command the exact same attention as Prizm, but its top parallels like Black Prizm are still meaningful hobby barometers.
• One‑of‑ones are unique markets. Without recurring comps, prices can vary widely depending on timing, player narrative, and who shows up to bid.

The $16,470 sale of the 2023 Panini Select Black Prizm #504 Michael Penix Jr. Rookie Card (#1/1) in PSA MINT 9 at Goldin on January 4, 2026, is best viewed as a snapshot of how the hobby currently values ultra‑scarce, high‑end Penix rookies — not as a fixed rule for what similar cards must do in the future.

As always, collectors benefit from tracking multiple recent sales across sets, parallels, and grades before making decisions about buying, selling, or holding their own cards.