2005 Exquisite Aaron Rodgers Holofoil RPA PSA 10 Sale

Aaron Rodgers’ true rookie grails sit in a very small, very serious corner of the modern football market—and few are more important than his 2005 Upper Deck Exquisite Collection Autograph Patch cards.

Goldin’s February 8, 2026 sale of a 2005 Upper Deck Exquisite Collection Autograph Patch Holofoil #106 Aaron Rodgers Rookie Card, graded PSA GEM MT 10 and numbered 2/5, realized $14,640. For a modern Hall of Fame–tier quarterback, this is a key data point for high‑end collectors trying to understand where Rodgers’ top‑shelf rookies stand today.

Below, we break down what this card is, why it matters, and how this sale fits into the broader market.

The card at a glance

Card: 2005 Upper Deck Exquisite Collection Autograph Patch Holofoil #106 Aaron Rodgers
Player: Aaron Rodgers, Green Bay Packers
Year/Set: 2005 Upper Deck Exquisite Collection Football
Card type: Rookie card (true RPA—Rookie Patch Autograph)
Parallel: Holofoil, serial numbered 2/5
Autograph: Signed, on‑card (Rodgers signed directly on the card)
Relic: Game‑used jersey patch
Grading company: PSA
Grade: PSA GEM MT 10 (Gem Mint)
Population: Pop 2 (only two copies at this grade in PSA’s population report at time of sale)

The base Rodgers Exquisite RPA is already one of his flagship rookies—meaning it’s widely recognized as one of his most important and desirable rookie cards. The Holofoil parallel, limited to just five copies, pushes the rarity even further. When you combine:

Ultra‑low print run (/5)
On‑card autograph
Game‑used patch
True rookie card from a premium product
PSA 10 grade with a population of only 2

…you get a card that sits firmly at the top of the Rodgers hierarchy for long‑term collectors.

Why 2005 Exquisite matters for football collectors

Upper Deck Exquisite Collection was one of the defining high‑end products of the 2000s. It helped establish the modern idea of a premium “RPA” (Rookie Patch Auto) as the key chase card for serious player collectors.

For 2005 football specifically, Exquisite is important because it anchors the rookie offerings of a strong quarterback class that includes Aaron Rodgers. While Rodgers spent his early seasons behind Brett Favre, his eventual MVP seasons and Super Bowl win retroactively turned these early Exquisite cards into core hobby assets.

For collectors, 2005 Exquisite Rodgers RPAs check several important boxes:

Era: Modern, but pre‑ultra‑modern manufacturing volume. Print runs are published and meaningfully low.
Design and prestige: Exquisite carries a reputation similar to what National Treasures would later become—an accepted “premium tier” brand.
On‑card autos and game‑used patches: Two features that remain central to how collectors define a high‑end rookie.

The Holofoil /5 is a premium parallel of an already premium card, which is why these rarely surface in public auction.

Grading, pop report, and scarcity

A pop report (population report) is the grading company’s count of how many copies of a card exist at each grade. For a card already limited to five copies, the grading population becomes particularly important.

PSA Grade: GEM MT 10 (Gem Mint)
PSA Pop: 2 in PSA 10

When the entire print run is five cards, and only two of those have achieved a PSA 10, the market is effectively dealing with a micro‑supply. That combination—true RPA, /5 parallel, and top possible grade—helps explain why even modest pricing moves can attract attention from high‑end player and set collectors.

Market context and recent sales

Public data on this exact 2005 Exquisite Holofoil #106 Rodgers /5 in PSA 10 is limited, for a simple reason: there are only five copies to begin with, and just two in this grade. Cards like this do not appear often at auction, and when they do, they are often placed in long‑term collections.

To understand the Goldin result, collectors typically look at:

Comps (comparable sales): other sales of the same card or similar versions—such as different grades, non‑Holofoil Exquisite RPAs, or alternative premium Rodgers rookies from the same era.
Related parallels: non‑Holofoil Exquisite Rodgers RPAs numbered to higher runs, which tend to sell more frequently and provide a pricing “floor” for rarer versions.

Recent public sales of Rodgers’ key Exquisite rookies have shown:

Strong differentiation between lower grades and GEM‑level copies.
A clear premium for the rarest parallels (like /5 Holofoil) relative to more common numbering.
Relatively low transaction volume, which means each confirmed sale meaningfully updates the market’s sense of value.

Within that context, the $14,640 Goldin result on February 8, 2026 sits as a useful reference point but not necessarily a definitive “ceiling” or “floor.” With so few copies in existence and changing demand over time, pricing can vary noticeably from sale to sale.

Why collectors care about this specific card

From a collector’s perspective, this card brings several layers of significance:

True Exquisite RPA: For many advanced collectors, Rodgers’ true Exquisite RPA is on the short list of his most important cards, alongside other key early high‑end issues.
Holofoil /5 parallel: A step above the standard version in scarcity and perceived prestige, adding an extra layer of chase for player and set collectors.
On‑card autograph: Preferred over sticker autographs because the player signs directly on the card surface, which many consider more visually and historically appealing.
Game‑used jersey patch: As game‑used relics become less common in newer products, earlier sets that clearly emphasize game‑used material stand out more for collectors who value that connection to the field.
PSA GEM MT 10, Pop 2: For those who focus on condition rarity, being 1 of 2 known PSA 10s is a strong differentiator.

This combination positions the card as both a player‑centric grail and a set‑builder’s prize.

What the $14,640 Goldin sale tells us

The February 8, 2026 sale at Goldin does a few things for the Rodgers market:

Updates price expectations: With limited prior public sales for PSA 10 Holofoil copies, this result provides a fresh benchmark for future negotiations and auctions.
Reinforces Exquisite’s status: Even as newer products and designs enter the hobby, early‑ to mid‑2000s Exquisite continues to command attention and meaningful prices.
Highlights condition scarcity: The premium attached to a pop‑2 PSA 10, relative to more commonly seen lower grades or different parallels, underlines how sharply the market now distinguishes between condition tiers.

It’s also worth framing this as one data point, not a guarantee of future performance. The ultra‑low population means that a single motivated buyer or seller can noticeably influence reported prices in the short term.

Takeaways for different types of collectors

Whether you’re new to the hobby, coming back after a break, or already active, here are some practical notes:

If you’re newer to football cards

A “true RPA” from a recognized premium brand (like Exquisite) is often treated as a core rookie for star players.
Serial numbered cards (like /5) tell you how many copies exist; the lower the number, the scarcer the card.
Gem Mint grades (PSA 10, BGS 9.5/10, etc.) command a noticeable premium, especially when the overall population is tiny.

If you’re a returning or active hobbyist

Use this sale as a reference point, but not a rigid rule. With only five copies, pricing can move differently than it does for more liquid cards.
When looking at comps, weigh differences in:
- Parallel (Holofoil /5 vs higher‑print versions)
- Grading company and subgrades (if applicable)
- Eye appeal (patch quality, autograph strength, centering).
For long‑term collecting, clarity of provenance—like a known Goldin sale date of February 8, 2026—can be a plus, especially for truly elite pieces.

If you sell or trade

Cards at this level often move via auction houses, consignments, or direct high‑end networking instead of only on fixed‑price marketplaces.
Detailed listing information—clear images of the patch and autograph, grade cert numbers, and pop report references—matters more as you move into premium territory.

Final thoughts

The 2005 Upper Deck Exquisite Collection Autograph Patch Holofoil #106 Aaron Rodgers, numbered 2/5 and graded PSA GEM MT 10 (Pop 2), is not just another rookie card. It represents a tightly defined slice of early high‑end football collecting—on‑card, game‑used, ultra‑low‑print, and anchored in a product line that helped shape the modern RPA.

Goldin’s February 8, 2026 sale at $14,640 gives collectors a fresh, concrete data point for one of Rodgers’ most important rookies. In a market where true Exquisite RPAs rarely surface, every public result helps refine our understanding of how the hobby currently values one of the defining quarterbacks of his era.

As always, it’s a snapshot, not a promise—use it as context, alongside your own collecting goals and preferences, as you navigate the high‑end football card landscape.