2019 Ohtani Finest SuperFractor BGS 9.5 Sells

2019 Topps Finest SuperFractor #100 Shohei Ohtani (#1/1) – BGS 9.5 Sells for $43,920

On December 7, 2025, Goldin closed a notable ultra‑modern baseball sale: a 2019 Topps Finest SuperFractor #100 Shohei Ohtani (#1/1), graded BGS GEM MINT 9.5, finished at $43,920.

For a non‑rookie, non‑autographed card, this is a meaningful data point in the ongoing story of how the hobby values Shohei Ohtani’s true one‑of‑one (1/1) chrome‑style parallels.

In this breakdown, we’ll walk through what the card is, why it matters, and how this sale fits into the broader Ohtani market.

Card overview: what exactly sold?

Here’s how this card breaks down in hobby terms:

Player: Shohei Ohtani
Team: Los Angeles Angels
Year: 2019
Product / Set: Topps Finest Baseball
Card number: #100
Parallel: SuperFractor (gold, spiral "super" pattern, serial numbered 1/1)
Serial numbering: #1/1 – the only copy produced
Rookie status: Not a rookie card (Ohtani’s main MLB rookies are from 2018 products), but still an early‑career key parallel
Autograph / relic: Non‑auto, no patch – pure chrome parallel
Era: Ultra‑modern (late‑2010s)
Grading company: Beckett Grading Services (BGS)
Grade: BGS GEM MINT 9.5

BGS 9.5 is Beckett’s standard “gem mint” level, typically meaning the card is extremely clean with only minor, hard‑to‑see flaws. For a chromium‑stock 1/1 like a SuperFractor, centering and surface are usually the main grade drivers.

Even though this is not Ohtani’s flagship or true rookie, it combines three things collectors track closely:

Topps chrome‑style brand (Topps Finest)
SuperFractor parallel (the highest parallel tier in most Topps chrome lines)
A gem‑level grade from a major third‑party grader (BGS)

Why SuperFractors matter

For newer or returning collectors: a SuperFractor is typically the top‑tier parallel in Topps chrome‑style releases. They are:

Serial numbered 1/1 – there is only one copy of each SuperFractor card.
Recognizable by a gold spiral / swirl pattern on a chrome finish.
Considered the true ceiling parallel for many player collectors in a given set.

Because there is only one SuperFractor per player per checklist, they effectively function as a “grail” for collectors who chase a specific athlete or rainbow (collecting all color parallels of a card).

In Ohtani’s case, his 2018 SuperFractors from products like Topps Chrome and Bowman’s Best are often viewed as higher‑tier targets because they are from his rookie year. However, early‑career non‑rookie Supers – like this 2019 Finest – still matter, especially as Ohtani’s broader card market has matured.

Market context: putting $43,920 into perspective

The sale price converts directly from the provided cents amount:

Final price: $43,920 (hammer plus any applicable buyer’s premium, as recorded by Goldin)
Auction house: Goldin
Sale date (UTC): 2025‑12‑07

Because this is a true 1/1, there is no deep history of exact same‑card comps ("comps" meaning recent comparable sales used as a reference). Instead, collectors look at:

Sales of other Ohtani SuperFractors from various years and sets.
Sales of 2019 Topps Finest Ohtani parallels (like Red Refractors /5, Orange /25, Gold /50) as rough benchmarks.
The broader Ohtani high‑end market: SuperFractors, low‑numbered autographs, and patch autos.

Across public auction data prior to late 2025, a few consistent themes have emerged for Ohtani:

Rookie‑year Supers (2018) and on‑card autos from top brands tend to command the highest prices, often deep into five‑ or six‑figure territory depending on issue and grade.
Non‑rookie Supers from respected chrome brands (Finest, Chrome, Bowman’s Best, etc.) generally sit in a second tier of value, with prices influenced heavily by timing (season performance, awards, and general hobby sentiment).

Within that framework, this $43,920 result for a non‑rookie, non‑autographed SuperFractor in BGS 9.5 aligns with Ohtani’s status as one of the most collected active players in the hobby. It sits below the peak territory reserved for his premier rookies and signed 1/1s, but still clearly in the high‑end lane of modern singles.

Because 1/1s do not change hands often, it’s more useful to view this as a fresh data point for how the market is currently treating high‑grade, early‑career Ohtani Supers than as a rigid price anchor.

Collector significance: where this card fits in the Ohtani hierarchy

For serious Ohtani collectors and set builders, this card checks several important boxes.

1. Early‑career snapshot

2019 is Ohtani’s second year on widely available MLB cards. Chronologically, this places the card just after his true rookies, during a period when collectors were still forming long‑term views on his ceiling as a two‑way player.

While 2018 remains the focus for rookie‑card purists, early‑career cards from 2019 and 2020 have increasingly become “next tier” targets as top‑end 2018 inventory has been locked away into collections or very long‑term holds.

2. Topps Finest as a brand

Topps Finest traces back to the 1990s and has a long history in the chrome card space.

For modern collectors, it sits in a tier of:

Recognizable chrome stock
Strong on‑card autograph checklists
A full rainbow of parallels, including SuperFractors

Although it is usually a bit behind flagship Topps Chrome in brand hierarchy, Finest SuperFractors are still viewed as meaningful 1/1s, especially for star players.

3. The SuperFractor factor

From a collecting standpoint, a SuperFractor 1/1 often acts as a “stopper” for a player rainbow. If you collect Ohtani’s 2019 Finest parallel run, the SuperFractor is the piece that completes the project.

Because there is only one, ownership often changes hands rarely. Each public auction becomes a small event in the micro‑market for that player and year.

Grading: BGS GEM MINT 9.5

Beckett’s GEM MINT 9.5 grade indicates the card is in extremely high condition. While population reports ("pop reports" – counts of how many copies of a card have received each grade) matter less for 1/1s, the grade still impacts liquidity and perceived desirability.

Key points:

A high grade on a 1/1 functions as an additional confidence signal for buyers, especially for online auctions.
With only one copy in existence, the grade can influence how future buyers remember the card, even though no direct 1:1 comparisons exist.

For this Ohtani, the combination of:

Early‑career year (2019)
Chrome finish
SuperFractor 1/1
BGS GEM MINT 9.5

creates a clean, high‑end profile that fits naturally into existing advanced Ohtani collections.

What could be driving interest now?

Shohei Ohtani’s broader card market has been shaped by a few consistent factors:

Unique two‑way profile: As a legitimate high‑level hitter and pitcher, Ohtani occupies a historical lane with very few comparisons.
Awards and milestones: MVP seasons, home run totals, and pitching performances have repeatedly moved sentiment around his cards.
Team and market changes: Big‑market signings, playoff appearances, or deep postseason runs can bring new waves of attention.

By late 2025, Ohtani is firmly established as a hobby cornerstone. Rather than reacting wildly to single‑season swings, the market now treats many of his cards—especially high‑end 1/1s—as longer‑term, prestige‑type holdings.

Within that context, this 2019 Topps Finest SuperFractor 1/1 BGS 9.5 functions less as a speculative play and more as a trophy piece for an Ohtani or modern baseball collector.

How collectors can use this sale as a reference

For active hobbyists and small sellers, this Goldin result does not mean every Ohtani parallel has moved to this level. It does, however, offer a few useful takeaways:

Hierarchy matters
Rookie year, autograph status, set prestige, and parallel level all stack together. A non‑rookie, non‑auto SuperFractor can still achieve a strong result if the player is important enough.
1/1s set their own lanes
One‑of‑ones trade rarely and often at wide price bands. Instead of treating any single sale as a hard “comp,” it’s more realistic to view it as a data point in a range.
Brand recognition still counts
Topps Finest is a long‑running brand with an established chrome identity. That heritage, combined with Ohtani’s profile, supports results like this more than a random low‑end 1/1 from a less familiar product would.
Grading is a tie‑breaker, not the whole story
On a unique card, grade is part of the story but not the only factor. Player, year, parallel, and set still do most of the heavy lifting.

Final thoughts

The 2019 Topps Finest SuperFractor #100 Shohei Ohtani (#1/1) – BGS GEM MINT 9.5 closing at $43,920 via Goldin on December 7, 2025 is a clear, public marker of how the hobby currently values:

Early‑career Ohtani 1/1s
Non‑rookie SuperFractors from respected chrome brands
High‑grade, non‑autographed ultra‑modern grail pieces

For collectors tracking Ohtani’s long‑term card market, this sale complements the bigger headlines around his rookie Supers and top autos by filling in the picture of his broader high‑end ecosystem.

As always, any one auction result should be treated as information, not a guarantee. But for those building Ohtani PCs (personal collections) or mapping out the modern baseball landscape, this Goldin sale is a data point worth bookmarking.